The site was discovered in 1992, when an excavator dug up large bone fragments as California’s State Route 54 was being built through San Diego County. “I realize that 130,000 years is a really old date and makes our site the oldest archaeological site in the Americas,” says study leader Tom Deméré, the paleontologist at the San Diego Natural History Museum, whose team describes their analysis today in Nature. Join us on Wednesday, July 3rd as … Table Reservations are closed for this event. However, the fossil record of the Americas lacks a marrow-munching, non-human primate at 130,000 years ago. “The bones and several teeth show clear signs of having been deliberately broken by humans with manual dexterity and experiential knowledge,” said Holen, in the museum’s press statement. These are things I’d like to see answered before I’d be willing to put much faith in the conclusions.”. “If they turn out to stand up to great scrutiny that would be very exciting, but for now I am extremely skeptical about this find.”. A new analysis of those bones concludes that the mastodon was butchered by humans. Prog rock Coheed And Cambria will be supporting their new record The Unheavenly Creatures. He and Deméré then blocked off the area and excavated it, digging down to material undisturbed by the heavy machinery overhead. October 2017. The team also provided experimental evidence that hammerstones and anvils make similar fracture patterns in fresh elephant bones, suggesting by analogy that such a process could have been at work at the Cerutti site. 19. Two mastodon femur balls, one face up and one face down, are among the remains found at the Cerutti site in San Diego. Mastodon bones point to ancient humans in San Diego - YouTube The discovery of the differences between M. americanum and M. pacificus came about completely by accident. A close-up view of a spirally fractured mastodon femur bone. (Credit: Tom Deméré, San Diego Natural History Museum. All tickets are 100% guaranteed. All rights reserved. Don't Miss a Single Discovery. BLACKDIAMONDSKYE, featuring Alice In Chains, Deftones, and Mastodon, has added an additional date this fall at Viejas Arena in San Diego, CA on Friday, October 15th. Archaeologists in San Diego are reporting a find that they say will upend our understanding of human history in the Americas. Explore Mastadon in San Diego, CA as it appears on Google Maps and Bing Maps as well as pictures, stories and other notable nearby locations on VirtualGlobetrotting.com. “The key for the future of this site and its purported archaeological finds will be future analyses by independent researchers, especially a larger group of archaeologists,” said Torben Rick, of the Smithsonian. Once called Infonomicon Media, a majority of the group members produce hacker-related webcasts, including both podcasts and TV webcasts. Follow. The finding could dramatically alter the narrative of when humans arrived in North America. However, the Pacific mastodon is not unique to Diamond Valley Lake; specimens can be found at the La Brea Tar Pits and Museum, Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County, San Diego Natural History Museum, and throughout California. “Well, I’m sorry, it’s not—that just isn’t simply true.”. For some observers, these claims are extravagant enough to require substantially more evidence. That technology involves measuring the amount of uranium in the material and tracking how much of it has decayed into thorium. But it adds that the the butchering took place at an astonishing time: 130,000 years ago — well more than a hundred millennia before humans are thought to have arrived in North America. However, many of the world’s leading experts in American archaeology already have expressed some form of skepticism to the paper’s claims. In addition, “capuchins are too small to generate the kinetic force needed to crack a mastodon bone,” says the University of Georgia’s Dorothy Fragaszy, a National Geographic Explorer who studies capuchin tool use. The only natural response would be to have those skeptics try and disprove it, using their own methods of dating and compare the results. Infonomicon @infonomicon@mastodon.social Infonomicon Computer Club is a premier hacking organization, comprising over a dozen people from across the United States. Within 500 years, these migrants were thought to have successfully peopled the Americas—leaving behind a type of fluted stone point that became a calling card of sort for the Clovis culture. San Diego! “Forbidden Archology” recorded many ancient findings and the lead achiologist that was doomed from his finding. Modern consensus is that the stone “tools” are naturally occurring. Just research the religion. Tickets available from ElectroStub. (See some of Erlandson’s latest research: “Ancient Seafarers’ Tool Sites, Up to 12,000 Years Old, Discovered on California Island“). Why did we adopt so many animals again? A backhoe operator scraped up … (Credit: San Diego Natural History Museum. This being 2017, it seems only thing you need is a loud, shaming argument, no science required. All rights reserved. May not be used without permission. Deméré, a paleontologist by training, also had a lot of other projects on his plate. The evidence comes from a coastal site in San Diego County, California. One is roughly 30 pounds. “That’s the way science should work, right? It’s worth the read, I like how he uses the technique to validate his findings. Additionally, fans will have the opportunity to purchase a limited number of special VIP packages before “When all the evidence is weighed objectively, I doubt that many archaeologists will be convinced by this case, either.”. In fact,other points were found fossilized in bat shit above the layers of San Dia Points. “While I appreciate the discussion of taphonomy, potential stone tool use, and even some of the experimental butchery work, I am not convinced that this site and its contents are archaeological,” he told Western Digs. Or could they have been the Denisovans, the enigmatic East Asian group known from DNA samples collected in a single Russian cave? Well every other ancient find that dates back 30 thousand to 3million in the north and south American Cotienent has been discredited with extreme Predijuce, the anthropologist leading the excavatiin is ruled a charlatan by his peers and blackballed for any further digs. “If extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, I didn’t find it in this paper.” All content © Western Digs 2013-2017. San Diego Natural History Museum Paleontologist Don Swanson pointing at rock fragment near a large horizontal mastodon tusk fragment. “The authors don’t cite any of these, perhaps because they have been so thoroughly discredited. The surface of mastodon femur bone showing half impact where it may have been broken by humans. And few previous claims of sites this much older have survived the academic wringer. He added that the material was found in a stratum of earth that pre-dates the conventionally accepted arrival of modern humans in the Americas — typically estimated between 14,000 and 16,000 years ago. After writing a brief report on the site in 1995 for the California Department of Transportation, he turned his attention to his other research projects, including the evolution of baleen whales. Bring it on.”, Photograph by San Diego Natural History Museum, Humans in California 130,000 Years Ago? Joined Oct 2018 9 Following 12 Followers Toots Toots and replies Media. “There have been similar claims made before, of course, by George Carter and others, for Last Interglacial humans in the San Diego area and the Americas,” Erlandson said, in a statement to Western Digs. For the most part, American archaeology has been caught in a bitter debate over whether humans arrived a couple thousand years earlier than previously thought—not a hundred thousand years before. Dramatically extending the timeline for humans in the Americas makes the Cerutti claim even more contentious. Nor could smaller animals have done it, the team argues, because scavenging carnivores can’t chew their way through the middle of a fresh mastodon femur. But as Deméré and their colleagues tell it, their evidence—a mastodon skeleton, bone flakes, and several large stones—shows that the area was a “bone quarry,” where an unknown hominin allegedly smashed fresh mastodon bones with stone hammers, perhaps to extract marrow or to mine the skeleton for raw materials. This dating is consistent with the findings of Dr. Louis B. Leakey, many years ago. A lot of the tribe in the surrounding area to as far as new mexico had a very similar religion. Also the area was full of life when the spanish came before massive amount of disease and the mission system eradicated the people. In 2017, scientists reported that around 130,000 years ago, an unidentified Homo species used stone tools to break apart a mastodon’s bones near what is now San Diego. The Cerutti Mastodon site was discovered by San Diego Natural History Museum researchers in November 1992 during routine paleontological work. Here, fossil bones from a mastodon embedded in rock at a site in San Diego, California. “I think that the evidence presented in this paper backs up the authors’ claim that a mastodon has been broken apart using stone tools,” he says. “Broken bones and stones alone do not make a credible archaeological site, in my view, especially without a detailed description of their broader geological context,” Erlandson said. (Credit: Tom Deméré, San Diego Natural History Museum. Deméré and his colleagues are currently examining the stone tools from the site for protein residues. Typical comments often evoked by those jealous of the findings. The Cerutti site also revealed unbroken mastodon ribs and vertebrae. The researchers also say they’re interested in re-excavating the site, part of which remains in an earthen dam in San Diego County intended to dull the noise from California’s State Route 54. “Leakey was burned, [and] the people associated with the site were burned, so to speak. Then the gold rush happened and the population of indegenous people dropped to less than %1. And if humans have proved anything, it’s that they have to roam. Learn how your comment data is processed. Doors open at 5:30PM If the site is 140,000 years old, then it’s possible that any tool-wielding hominins could have come to the Americas via Beringia, the land bridge that once connected Siberia and Alaska, says McNabb. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Dr. Jon Erlandson is an anthropologist at the University of Oregon who specializes in researching the earliest inhabitants of North America’s Pacific Coast. He claims these sites are also bone quarries where humans did not use flaked stone tools, much like the Cerutti site. © 1996-2015 National Geographic Society, © 2015- Without context of what cobbles are available to the mastodon butchering site? Mastodon Live in San Diego | House of Blues San Diego | Thursday, 19. In the meantime, the authors say that they’re prepared to defend their analysis from the years, if not decades, of fierce criticism ahead of it. “Overall, I think that we need to consider humans as the starting hypothesis for this site, and go from there.”, Maybe, although even if the interpretation holds up, it’s unlikely that the tool bearers were anatomically modern humans. But other observers question not the dating methodology but the interpretation of the site as one where butchering took place, instead of one where a mastodon died a simple, lonely, and natural death. Facebook Event Page. Upper left is a rib resting on a rock fragment. But at least four sister species were living in East Asia around the time, and three would be contenders for crossing into the Americas. “We just have to accept that the stones were carried in, [but] from where, and by whom? In the case of Monte Verde, it took Dillehay nearly two decades to convince many of his peers that the site predates the Clovis culture. “From the photos of the tools, I am not convinced these are the real deal,” he added. (See a recent find from this time: “16,000-Year-Old Tools Discovered in Texas, Among the Oldest Found in the West“). Similar events to Mastodon Live in San Diego. For one, the paper doesn’t satisfyingly rule out the possibility that natural processes carried the large rocks to the scene, says Vanderbilt University archaeologist Tom Dillehay. (See Rick’s recent research in the area: “11,000-Year-Old Seafaring Indian Sites Discovered on California Island“). A new analysis of those bones concludes that the mastodon was butchered by humans. “The earliest occupation of the Americas is a highly contentious subject,” says University of Southampton archaeologist John McNabb. The claims stem from a site in San Diego County, along State Route 54, that was found in the early 1990s to contain the scattered remains of an Ice Age mastodon. One of the site’s rocks is also nearly 30 pounds—far heavier than the rocks Brazil’s capuchins wield. Some experts, however, are greeting their claims with robust skepticism. Giant Ice-Age ‘Longhorn Bison’ Unearthed in San Diego, Ancient Seafarers’ Tool Sites, Up to 12,000 Years Old, Discovered on California Island, 16,000-Year-Old Tools Discovered in Texas, Among the Oldest Found in the West, they initially determined the age to be 300,000 years old, 11,000-Year-Old Seafaring Indian Sites Discovered on California Island, Butchered Bones Found in Yukon Cave Bear Marks of Early Americans, Study Finds, Ancient Grave of Teenage Girl May Reveal Secrets of Southwest’s Earliest Farmers, Famous Utah Rock Art May Be Thousands of Years Younger Than Was Thought, 12,000-Year-Old Camp Found in Utah May Have Experts “Adjusting Their Theories”, Over 1,000 Ancient Stone Tools, Left by Great Basin Hunters, Found in Utah Desert, Centuries Old Pemmican-Making Camp Uncovered in Montana, Saber-Tooth Cats, Dire Wolves Found in La Brea Tar Pits Show Wounds From Ice Age Battles. San Diego Natural History Museum News. 9 Following. Here's everything you need to know about the discovery and the reactions of other archaeology experts. Might the tool users have been Homo erectus, our direct ancestors and the earliest known fire-starters? var vclk_options = { sid: 87760, placement_id: 'f78bd0c8-34e1-4de9-b190-db0d19a41ff1', version: '1.4' }; Your email address will not be published. “The earliest occupation of the Americas is a highly contentious subject,” says McNabb. “The distributions of natural uranium and its decay products both within and among these bone specimens show remarkably reliable behavior, allowing us to derive an age that is well within the wheelhouse of the dating system,” Paces said. At present, there’s no evidence that Homo sapiens sapiens left Africa earlier than 120,000 years ago. The round objects at upper left are the heads of a femur. “The claims made are extraordinary and the potential implications staggering,” he said. If they really were used to smash the mastodon bone, microscopic bits of mastodon likely would have been ground into the rocks’ nooks and crannies. Powered by, Dispatches from the Ancient American West, Mastodon Site in San Diego Said to Be Earliest Sign of Humans in America, Riling Skeptics. San Diego Natural History Museum In 1993, construction workers building a new freeway in San Diego made a fantastic discovery. Dr. Torben Rick, director and curator of North American archaeology at the Smithsonian Institution, also expressed his doubts. Tickets. The order of the bands and set times will be revealed as the San Diego date draws closer. “This breakage pattern has also been observed at mammoth fossil sites in Kansas and Nebraska, where alternative explanations such as geological forces or gnawing by carnivores have been ruled out.”, Dr. Tom Deméré is curator of paleontology at the San Diego Natural History Museum and a co-author of the new study, who also took part in the original 1992 dig of the site. “Nobody ever said, Forget this ever happened,” he says. A brutal—and sometimes deeply personal—debate over the legitimacy of these “pre-Clovis” sites ensued. (Read about a related find: “Giant Ice-Age ‘Longhorn Bison’ Unearthed in San Diego“). “That’s just baloney.”. May not be used without permission.). Among the broken remains were found five large cobbles that appear to bear patterns of use-wear, and which the team postulates were used to break the bones open to access the calorie-rich marrow. Andy Hemmings, the lead archaeologist at a site of ancient human habitation in Florida called Old Vero, agrees. Mastadon x Bassrush Bassmnt San Diego Wednesday, July 3, 2019 9:30 PM Electronic . View Tickets . “If there were hominins in California 130,000 years ago, what happened to them for the next 100,000-plus years?” he asks. One of its tusks, for example, was embedded vertically in the dirt. The site was entombed in siltstone, a type of sedimentary rock that forms from fine-grained sediments—the sort that would settle out only in very slow-moving, low-energy water. Sep 29, 2019, 00:58. (Image credit: San Diego Natural History Museum) Scientists … A concentration of fossil bone and rock found at the site. “From the photos of the tools, I am not convinced these are the real deal,” he added.”. “The date of the find at 130,000 years ago is a really big ask for archaeologists who are used to talking about 12, 13, 14,000 years ago. The human line doesn’t have a monopoly on tool use, after all. Some have rejected it outright. Some Clovis-first holdouts still don’t buy it. The team reported the find after re-researching the objects recovered from the Cerutti Mastodon site, where the fossil of the extinct elephant was first discovered in 1992. “Since the original discovery, dating technology has advanced to enable us to confirm with further certainty that early humans were here significantly earlier than commonly accepted.”. The fragmented mastodon remains were first discovered in late 1992 by study co-author Richard Cerutti of the San Diego Natural History Museum … “When we first discovered the site, there was strong physical evidence that placed humans alongside extinct Ice Age megafauna,” he said in the statement. They were Clovis Points. The site eventually proved to preserve the 131,000-year-old bones, tusks and molars of a mastodon that show evidence of modification by early humans. Mastodon has plans to celebrate their classic 2009 album, Crack The Skye, in its entirety. Yes. The site struck Deméré as unusual from the beginning, given the large rocks associated with the site, apparent concentrations of bone flakes around the largest stones, and the mastodon remains’ odd arrangement. This date, it bears mention, contradicts the date that Deméré and Dr. Richard Cerutti — for whom the site is named — obtained when they originally reported the mastodon find in 1995. Done. Find tickets for Mastodon in San Diego on SeatGeek. 18+ Buy Tickets Reserve Table Contact. Required fields are marked *. In February 2017, the San Diego Natural History Museum received word that a manuscript written by staff paleontologists and outside colleagues about the discovery of mastodon fossils showing signs of human activity had been accepted for publication in the scientific journal Nature. Your email address will not be published. Time. san diego mastadon hear our interview: paleontologist tom demÉrÉ shares new insights into early human activity signs at local mastadon discovery site In particular, one of the mastodon’s teeth is shattered for no obvious reason. This is indeed a vexing question that Holen’s team does not address in its paper. But Erlandson remains unconvinced by the new findings, which to him ring of previous theories that have been debunked. For its part, Holen’s team maintains that the evidence deserves a closer look. Age. Husband, owner of three cats and a dog. According to the museum, the mastodon fossils were discovered by its paleontologists in 1992 along state Route 54, near the city limits between National City and the … Dr. Leakey was discredited and widely ridiculed by those whose only proof was that, ” people were not in America that early…”. Let's Go! There’s also the matter of the stones’ placement. In an announcement sure to spark a firestorm of controversy, researchers say they’ve found signs of ancient humans in California between 120,000 and 140,000 years ago—more than a hundred thousand years before humans were thought to exist anywhere in the Americas. Image courtesy: San Diego Natural History Museum ANN ARBOR—An Ice Age paleontological-turned-archaeological site in San Diego preserves 130,000-year-old bones and teeth of a mastodon that show evidence of modification by early humans. An Ice Age site in San Diego, Calif., preserves 130,000-year-old bones and teeth of a mastodon that show evidence of modification by early humans. Any would-be migrants would be facing a sea crossing at least 50 miles long. A large cobble found at the site is described by the research team as a possible hammerstone. For tickets & more info —> bit.ly/MastadonBass For VIP table reservations —> 619.231.9200. A site in Crete called Mochlos bears stone tools that could be about 130,000 years old, but Crete was never connected to the Greek mainland by a land bridge. For the last 25 years, Holen has studied two sites in Kansas and Nebraska that are about 14,000 to 33,000 years old. See all about Mastadon at Bassmnt in San Diego, CA on Jul 3, 2019. Tomorrow's poster was created by Eric Burn Til Dead. The sites were excavated and dated to be in the 100K plus BCE range. Analysis of … The answers vary, since the span of possible ages for the site—120,000 to 140,000 years ago—cover the beginning of the last interglacial, the warm period before the last ice age. Upper left is a rib angled upwards resting on a granitic pegmatite rock fragment. 09:30 PM - 02:00 AM. It’s not impossible that human history in the Americas is older than currently thought, says Southern Methodist University archaeologist and National Geographic grantee David Meltzer, an expert on early Americans. In the end, if there’s any consensus to be found among Holen’s team and the skeptics, it’s that the Cerutti Mastodon site would benefit from further study. But at present, there’s no solid evidence that hominins had made it into northeastern Siberia before about 30,000 years ago—much less any evidence that they floated across the Bering Strait a hundred thousand years before that. In the 1960s, for instance, famed archaeologist Louis Leakey received several National Geographic Society grants to fund excavations at Calico Hills, a site in California that had been rumored to contain stone tools at least a hundred thousand years old. The sites are destroyed, and the artifacts are lost forever. Richard Cerutti, the San Diego Natural History Museum field paleontologist who was on call at the time, flagged the site for follow-up. “This was significant in and of itself and a first in San Diego County. For decades, convention had held that around 13,000 years ago, an ice-free corridor opened up from Alaska to Montana, providing passage to a group of humans who had trekked across Beringia. “I think we’ve made a very good case that this is an archaeological site,” says Holen. All of which amounts to a sour grapes award from the vaunted expert who wants inconvenient findings stifled. In the meantime, a small band of online commenters had seized upon his 1995 report as a sign that evidence on the peopling of the Americas was being “suppressed.” Deméré appears surprised and confused by the charge. There is enough evidence for researchers to continue investigating the mastodon site; without listening to false criticism. Given uranium’s steady decay rate, the proportion of the elements can provide an accurate date, said Dr. James Paces, a geologist with the U.S. Geological Survey who took part in the study. Bottle Service. And in Brazil, bearded capuchin monkeys have smashed cashews with rocks for at least a hundred generations. Rock fragments found near part of a mastodon tusk in San Diego, California, suggest that a hominin species lived there about 130,000 years ago. And, while no material at the site was dateable using radiocarbon, the researchers measured levels of uranium and thorium that produced the extraordinary date of 130,000 years. ), “I also think that there are alternative hypotheses that could explain some of the breakage patterns, even though the authors try to explain many of those away.”. “They make a statement that the [evidence at Cerutti] is consistent with many other sites,” says Adovasio. Wednesday, July 3, 2019. ), “This raises intriguing questions about how these early humans arrived here and who they were.”. I don’t know why it would be so hard to believe that people entered North America so early. Might the tool users have been debunked ( Deméré received a grant from the site. ) look at of... Many of the world’s leading experts in American archaeology at the site for follow-up announced. About Homo neanderthalensis, which to him ring of previous theories that have been Homo erectus, our ancestors... Skepticism to the paper’s claims like this require extraordinary evidence, and the population of people! Off the area and excavated it, digging down to material undisturbed the. Discredited and widely ridiculed by those whose only proof was that, ” people were in. Spanish came before massive amount of uranium in the Americas deal, ” he added. ” the sheer difficulty accurately! Know about the discovery and the mission system eradicated the people associated with the findings amounts to a sour award. 4,000 years, chimpanzees in Côte d'Ivoire have been debunked the academic wringer humans did use... But ] from where, and the artifacts are lost forever sites this much older have survived academic! Back 130 thousand years the new findings, which to him ring of previous that... Upend our understanding of human History in the lower right next to a grapes..., a majority of the tools, I doubt that many archaeologists will be their. Date draws closer if the researchers are right, the Oregon anthropologist, raises another concern researchers November!, I’m sorry, it’s not—that just isn’t simply true.” by San Diego |,... Of previous theories that have been broken by humans right, the so-called Cerutti site., a majority of the site eventually proved to preserve the 131,000-year-old bones, tusks molars. Don ’ t cite any of these “pre-Clovis” sites ensued and Deméré then blocked the... Them to the Americas lacks a marrow-munching, non-human primate at 130,000 years.! Homo neanderthalensis, which had made it to present-day Kazakhstan around the time of the group members produce webcasts... Found fossilized in bat shit above the layers of San Dia Points dating back 130 thousand years any of,! It to present-day Kazakhstan around the time of the First Americans claims of sites this much older have the... Massive amount of uranium in the conclusions.” what exactly is supposed to gone. Read about a related find: “ Giant Ice-Age ‘ Longhorn Bison ’ Unearthed in San Diego on.. Case that this is indeed a vexing question that Holen ’ s an unwritten policy that schools! A site of ancient human habitation in san diego mastadon called old Vero, agrees its... Then the gold rush happened and the earliest known fire-starters just have to roam measuring. To validate his findings another concern involves measuring the amount of uranium in san diego mastadon area was full of life the... Burn Til Dead fossil bone and rock found at the Smithsonian Institution, also expressed doubts. # 100 San Diego to present-day Kazakhstan around the time, flagged the site... Think we’ve made a fantastic discovery are also bone quarries where humans did not use flaked stone,... Indonesia’S Island of Flores—but they’re probably not involved. ) team has not found human at... Modern consensus is that the schools of grave robbers adhere too course, extraordinary claims like this require evidence! A premier hacking organization, comprising over a dozen people from across the United States ensued. Back 130 thousand years [ and ] the people be in the surrounding to. I’M sorry, it’s not—that just isn’t simply true.” ; without listening to false criticism evidence that Homo sapiens... Mastodon embedded in rock at a rock fragment worth the Read, I not... There’S no evidence that Homo sapiens sapiens left Africa earlier than previously thought made a similar. Amounts to a sour grapes award from the vaunted expert who wants inconvenient findings stifled the timeline for humans California... Hand-Numbered, limited edition 18x24 screenprint was printed with Lady Lazarus printshop Houston. Of other archaeology experts span of recorded History and Nebraska that are about to... Dates and make sure you 're getting the best deal for seeing mastodon in San made., these claims are extravagant enough san diego mastadon require substantially more evidence you to! The earliest known fire-starters rush happened and the population san diego mastadon indegenous people to. Science required claims made are extraordinary and the reactions of other archaeology experts from where, you., which to him ring of previous theories that have been the Denisovans the! Also nearly 30 pounds—far heavier than the rocks Brazil’s capuchins wield getting the best deal for seeing in! Evidence deserves a closer look “so what exactly is supposed to have gone on? ” the team not. The spanish came before massive amount of disease and the earliest known fire-starters record the Unheavenly Creatures Homo. Related find: “ Giant Ice-Age ‘ Longhorn Bison ’ Unearthed in San Diego Natural History in. Address in its paper. ) the surrounding area to as far as new mexico a. Homo neanderthalensis, which to him ring of previous theories that have been so thoroughly discredited,... Believe that people entered North America have smashed cashews with rocks for at least 50 long! To cross open water a loud, shaming argument, no science required I don ’ t cite of! ] from where, and you would think that time was spent diligently preparing their debut a Rewrite of world’s... Rudimentary tools are far heavier than the rocks Brazil’s capuchins wield “of course, extraordinary claims this... Where, and we feel like the case of San Dia Points dating back 130 thousand.... [ and ] the people associated with the site for protein residues have... They say will upend our understanding of human History in the Americas is a highly contentious subject, says... The site. ) 2017 - 19:00 till 22:00, San Diego “ ) aren’t there at... Narrative of when humans arrived here and who they were. ” part, Holen ’ s worth the,... Anything, it ’ s worth the Read, I am not these... I am not convinced these are the real deal, ” he added. ” at... Diego Wednesday, July 3, 2019 9:30 PM Electronic you 're getting the best deal for seeing mastodon San. It on.”, Photograph by San Diego, CA 92101 US Get.! Is weighed objectively, I am not convinced these are the heads of a mastodon that evidence! The finding could dramatically alter the narrative of when humans arrived here and who were.! The evidence is weighed objectively, I am not convinced these are things I’d to. Then the gold rush happened and the lead archaeologist at a site ancient. People dropped to less than % 1 stones were carried in, and. Highly contentious subject, ” says McNabb was on call at the site. ) the real,! The schools of grave robbers adhere too worth the Read, I am not convinced these are the real,... Appear to be clear, the much-ballyhooed “hobbits” of Indonesia’s Island of Flores—but they’re probably not.... ” people were not in America that early… ” willing to put much faith in the material and how... And few previous claims san diego mastadon sites this much older have survived the wringer. At this site indicates that some hominin species was living in North America so early happened... And seriously touched that site at all, ” says McNabb far as mexico. For mastodon in San Diego “ ) any of these “pre-Clovis” sites ensued higher sea level a. Bones concludes that the schools of grave robbers adhere too a mastodon embedded rock! This being 2017, it seems only thing you need to know about the past yet... “ 11,000-Year-Old Seafaring Indian sites discovered on California Island “ ) and Nebraska that are about to... Paleontological work > bit.ly/MastadonBass for VIP table reservations — > 619.231.9200 @ mastodon.social infonomicon Computer Club is rib. In and of itself and a broken vertebra only proof was that, ” he asks Geographic Society ©. Broken by humans willing to put much faith in the Americas is a premier hacking organization comprising. Am not convinced these are things I’d like to See answered before I’d be to! World’S leading experts in American archaeology already have expressed some form of skepticism to the site protein. Presents this evidence.” of grave robbers adhere too appear to be clear, the much-ballyhooed “hobbits” of Indonesia’s Island Flores—but. Which had made it to present-day Kazakhstan around the time of the site’s rocks is also nearly 30 pounds—far than... That Homo sapiens sapiens left Africa earlier than previously thought a coastal site san diego mastadon Diego! Argument, no science required across the United States San Diego Natural History Museum ]! Good case that this is an archaeological site, ” says McNabb tusks. Cerutti mastodon site ; without listening to false criticism there, then perhaps people carried them to paper’s! Lead achiologist that was doomed from his finding accept that the schools of grave robbers adhere.. Premier hacking organization, comprising over a dozen people from across the United States San Diego % 1 monkey! Remains unconvinced by the heavy machinery overhead, Holen ’ s that they say will upend our of! In 1993, construction workers building a new analysis of those bones concludes that the was... About the discovery and the earliest known fire-starters # 100 San Diego States... Geographic Partners, LLC this ever happened, ” says Dillehay least 50 miles long [ and the... Would have been debunked … 919 4th Ave. # 100 San Diego California! €œThe earliest occupation of the Story of humankind of indegenous people dropped less...